Powers v. Detroit Automobile Inter-Insurance Exchange , 427 Mich. 602 ( 1986 )

Riley, J.

(concurring in part and dissenting in part). I respectfully dissent from the opinion of my colleagues in Powers, Deyarmond, Nicholson, and Schiebout for the reasons set forth by former Chief Justice Coleman in her opinion in State Farm v Ruuska, 412 Mich 321, 353; 314 NW2d 184 (1982). I would hold that the nonowned automobile exclusion is enforceable.

Thus, I would reverse the decisions of the Court of Appeals in Powers and Schiebout, and affirm the decisions of the Court of Appeals in Deyarmond and Nicholson.

Finally, I am in accord with the result reached by my colleagues in Dennison.

Boyle, J., concurred with Riley, J.