Allegheny County Dept. of Public Works v. Com. of PA ( 2019 )

IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Allegheny County :
Department of Public Works, :
Petitioner :
:
v. :
:
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, : No. 473 F.R. 2015
Respondent : Argued: October 3, 2019
BEFORE: HONORABLE P. KEVIN BROBSON, Judge
HONORABLE CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge
HONORABLE ROBERT SIMPSON, Senior Judge
OPINION NOT REPORTED
MEMORANDUM OPINION
BY JUDGE FIZZANO CANNON FILED: October 24, 2019
Allegheny County Department of Public Works (Public Works)
petitions for review from an order of the Board of Finance and Revenue (Board)
dated July 16, 2015 denying its petitions seeking refunds for taxes paid pursuant to
the Liquid Fuels and Fuels Tax Act (Act), 75 Pa.C.S. §§ 9001-9022, for the years
2008 through 2013. The Board denied Public Works’ petitions because it failed to
provide proof of tax payment. We vacate the Board’s order and dismiss Public
Works’ petitions seeking refunds.
The parties stipulated to the following facts.1 In January 2015, Public
Works filed petitions with the Board requesting refunds for liquid fuels taxes paid
1
The stipulation of facts is binding and conclusive upon this Court though we may draw
our own legal conclusions from those facts. Norris v. Commonwealth, 625 A.2d 179, 182 (Pa.
Cmwlth. 1993).
for the years 2008 through 2013. Joint Stipulation of Facts (Stipulation) ¶¶ 3-8;
Reproduced Record (R.R.) 1a-7a. Public Works asserted in its petitions that it was
entitled to the refunds because “Allegheny County is a political subdivision of the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and is exempt from paying the [l]iquid [f]uels
[t]ax.” R.R. 11a, 18a, 22a, 26a, 30a, & 34a. The exemption to which Public Works
referred is in Section 9004(e)(4) of the Act, which provides that tax imposed “shall
not apply to liquid fuels, fuels or alternative fuels” delivered to a political
subdivision on presentation of evidence satisfactory to the [Department of Revenue
of the Commonwealth].” 75 Pa.C.S. § 9004(e)(4).2
On or about May 13, 2015, the Board held a hearing regarding Public
Works’ refund petitions for taxes paid from 2008 through 2013 and, at the hearing,
Public Works agreed to provide additional information regarding its appeals.
Stipulation ¶¶ 11-12. On May 28, 2015, a Board official sent follow-up
correspondence to Public Works requesting additional information to support the
2012 and 2013 petitions and requested that the information be provided within 20
days. Id. ¶¶ 13-15. On June 4, 2015, Public Works informed the Board that it was
obtaining the requested information and the Board entered an order deferring a
decision on Public Works’ petitions until a future meeting of the Board. Id. ¶¶ 16-
17. On July 2, 2015, a Board official contacted Public Works inquiring into whether
Public Works was still gathering additional information, but Public Works did not
respond to this inquiry. Id. ¶¶ 18-19. The Board subsequently rendered its decision
dated July 16, 2015, and mailed July 22, 2015, to deny Public Works’ petitions. Id.
¶ 20. The Board explained that Public Works “failed to provide proof of tax payment
for the periods in question. Consequently, no relief can be granted.” Id., Ex. H, pg.
2
The parties do not dispute that Public Works is a political subdivision.
2
2, R.R. 127a. On July 30, 2015, Public Works asked the Board to reconsider its
decision but the Board denied Public Works’ request. Stipulation ¶¶ 21-22.
Subsequently, Public Works filed a petition for review with this Court.3
Before this Court, Public Works argues that the Board erred when it
dismissed its requests for refunds4 because it provided “sufficient data to specify the
amount of tax paid.”5 Petition for Review (Petition) ¶ 5(b), R.R. 130a. Public Works
further contends that the Board erred by issuing its determination before Public
Works provided additional information and, additionally, erred by refusing to
reconsider its decision. Petition ¶ 5(c), R.R. 131a. Public Works seeks an order
reversing the Board’s determination and granting the requested refunds or,
3
This Court reviews de novo the determinations of the Board. Kelleher v. Commonwealth,
704 A.2d 729, 731 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1997). Although cases from the Board are addressed to our
appellate jurisdiction, we function as a trial court. Cooper v. Commonwealth, 700 A.2d 553, 554,
n.1 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1997).
4
Though Public Works asserts in its petition that the Board erred with respect to its decision
relating to the petitions seeking refunds for the years 2008 through 2013, Petition ¶ 5(b), R.R.
131a, Public Works represents in its Brief to this Court that the 2008 and 2009 petitions are not at
issue before this Court “[p]ursuant to a discussion between the parties.” Public Works’ Brief at 6,
n.1. Public Works seeks a refund in the amount of $120,015.25 for taxes paid for the years 2010
through 2013. Id. at 11.
5
Public Works argues that it attached several documents to its petitions to demonstrate the
fuel taxes paid. Public Works attached letters from Allegheny County’s fuel credit card system
vendor, WEX, Inc., for the periods at issue that show that Public Works “was charged the pump
price which included taxes” and “no adjustments were made to the account to remove these taxes
in this category on the monthly billing statement.” Public Works’ Brief at 10; R.R. 27a, 31a &
35a. Additionally, Public Works submitted a “Fleet Services Vehicle Analysis Report for each
calendar year stating the amount of fuel and the amount of reported tax for various Allegheny
County users.” Public Works’ Brief at 10; R.R. 41a & 123a. Finally, Public Works attached
Allegheny County’s reports entitled “A/P Payment History Detail Report” substantiating payments
made to WEX, Inc. for fuel purchases. Public Works’ Brief at 10; R.R. 1b-36b. We note that
Public Works numbered the reports as “R.R. 1b-36b” though the documents are included in the
reproduced record as opposed to the supplemental reproduced record. See Pa.R.A.P. 2173
(explaining that citations to the reproduced record are to include a small “a” whereas citations to
the supplemental reproduced record are to include a small “b”).
3
alternatively, an order reversing the Board’s determination and granting Public
Works leave to supplement the information already submitted to the Board. Petition
¶ 6, R.R. 131a. The Commonwealth counters that Public Works’ requests for
refunds should be rejected because Public Works filed the requests late and the
Board could not consider the matters. Commonwealth’s Brief at 10 & 13-14.6 Even
if Public Works had filed timely requests, it did not meet its burden because it did
not establish that “it actually paid the tax in question to the Commonwealth.” Id. at
14. Before we can reach the merits of Public Works’ appeal, we must first consider
whether Public Works’ petitions to the Board were timely filed.
Section 9017(a) of the Act allows the Department of Revenue to refund
taxes, penalties, interest, fines, additions and other money collected pursuant to this
chapter in accordance with the Tax Reform Code of 1971,7 except as provided in
subsection (a.1). 75 Pa.C.S. § 9017(a). Subsection (a.1) provides:
[T]he board may refund on an annual basis any tax
imposed by this chapter and collected by the department
upon liquid fuels or fuels delivered to any entity exempt
from tax under section 9004(e) (relating to imposition of
tax, exemptions and deductions) which has not been
claimed as exempt by the distributor or otherwise
6
The Commonwealth could not file an answer to the petition but is allowed to raise any
question for our review pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of Appellate Procedure 1571(e).
7
Section 3003.1 of the Act of March 4, 1971, P.L. 6, No. 2, as amended, added by Section
14 of the Act of July 1, 1985, P.L. No. 78, 72 P.S. § 10003.1. Section 3003.1 addresses petitions
for refunds and provides that a taxpayer that has actually paid tax to the Commonwealth, or its
agent or licensee, may petition the Department of Revenue for a refund or credit of the tax paid.
72 P.S. § 10003.1(a). Section 3003.1 further provides that “[e]xcept as otherwise provided by
statute, a petition for refund must be made to the department within three years of actual payment
of the tax . . . .” Id. (emphasis added). Subsection (a.1) of Section 9017 of the Act provides a
separate process to obtain refunds for the payment of taxes on liquid fuels or fuels delivered to any
entity exempt from tax.
4
refunded. The board may adopt regulations relating to the
proceedings for the administration of its duties under this
subsection.
75 Pa.C.S. § 9017(a.1) (emphasis added). The Commonwealth asserts that the
annual filing requirement is elaborated upon in the regulation at 61 Pa. Code §
303.12:
Claims for refunds by political subdivisions shall be made
annually, ending December 31, and shall be submitted to
the Board not later than March 31, of the succeeding year:
and the Board will refuse to consider a claim received or
postmarked after that date.
61 Pa. Code § 303.12 (emphasis added); Commonwealth’s Brief at 11. Reading the
Act and the regulation together, the Commonwealth argues that Public Works had
to file a claim for a refund with the Board “annually by March 31st of the succeeding
year.” Commonwealth’s Brief at 11. Upon review, we agree.
Section 9017(a.1) of the Act imposes on the Board a duty to refund
taxes on an “annual basis” imposed and collected by the Department of Revenue
upon liquid fuels or fuels delivered to any political subdivision. 75 Pa.C.S. §
9017(a.1). To enable the Board to refund taxes, the political subdivision must first
make a claim for a refund with the Board. The regulation provides the process for
political subdivisions to do so. See 61 Pa. Code § 303.12.8 The regulation states
that “[c]laims for refunds by political subdivisions shall be made annually, ending
December 31” and the political subdivision “shall” submit its claims to the Board no
8
Section 303.12 is part of Chapter 303 of Title 61. See 61 Pa. Code §§ 303.1-303.25.
Chapter 303 was “promulgated by the Board and the Department in order to effect refunds of liquid
fuels tax to political subdivisions as set forth in the act, in accordance with the opinion of the
Attorney General of the Commonwealth of July 28, 1970.” 61 Pa. Code § 303.1 (emphasis added).
5
later than “March 31, of the succeeding year.” Id. The regulation imposes a duty
on a political subdivision to file a claim and provides when the claim must be filed
to enable the Board to perform its duty, which is to refund taxes on an “annual basis.”
75 Pa.C.S. § 9017(a.1). Therefore, we conclude that Public Works had to file its
claims for refunds with the Board by no later than March 31st of the succeeding
year, as provided in the regulation, for the Board to consider its claims.
Here, Public Works did not file its petitions for liquid fuels tax refunds
for the years 2008 through 2013 on time. As provided in the Stipulation, Public
Works filed a petition with the Board on January 13, 2015 seeking a tax refund for
the period of January 1 through December 31 for the year 2013. Stipulation ¶ 3.
Because the claim for 2013 taxes was due by March 31, 2014, this petition was late.
Similarly, on January 28, 2015, Public Works filed the petitions with the Board
seeking a refund for taxes paid from January 1 through December 31 for the years
2008, 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012. Id. ¶¶ 4-8. But, these claims were to be filed
with the Board by March 31 of the succeeding year, that is, by March 31, 2009, 2010,
2011, 2012 and 2013, respectively, and, therefore, were also late. Because Public
Works did not submit its claims for refunds on time, the Board should have refused
to consider the claims.
We, therefore, vacate the Board’s order denying Public Works’
petitions for failure to provide proof of tax payment and dismiss Public Works’
petitions for failure to timely file its requests for refunds.
__________________________________
CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge
6
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Allegheny County :
Department of Public Works, :
Petitioner :
:
v. :
:
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, : No. 473 F.R. 2015
Respondent :
ORDER
AND NOW, this 24th day of October, 2019, the order of the Board of
Finance and Revenue dated July 16, 2015 is VACATED and the petitions filed by
the Allegheny County Department of Public Works seeking refunds for taxes paid
pursuant to the Liquid Fuels and Fuels Tax Act, 75 Pa.C.S. §§ 9001-22, for the years
2008 through 2013 are DISMISSED. Unless exceptions are filed within 30 days
pursuant to Pa.R.A.P. 1571(i), this order shall become final.
__________________________________
CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge