Com. v. Moody, C. ( 2015 )

J. S33010/15
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION – SEE SUPERIOR COURT I.O.P. 65.37
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
v. :
:
CHRISTIAN MOODY, : No. 2934 EDA 2014
:
Appellant :
Appeal from the Judgment of Sentence, September 17, 2014,
in the Court of Common Pleas of Delaware County
Criminal Division at No. CP-23-CR-0002459-2014
BEFORE: FORD ELLIOTT, P.J.E. DONOHUE AND LAZARUS, JJ.
MEMORANDUM BY FORD ELLIOTT, P.J.E.: FILED JULY 08, 2015
Christian Moody appeals from the judgment of sentence entered
following his conviction of false identification to a law enforcement officer.
His court-appointed counsel, Richard J. Blasetti, Esq., has filed a petition to
withdraw and accompanying Anders1 brief. After careful review, we grant
the petition to withdraw and affirm the judgment of sentence.
On January 3, 2014 at 2:30 a.m., a pedestrian in the parking lot of a
Wawa convenience store flagged down Officer Kevin Wiley. The man
reported a person inside the store acting suspiciously and another male
waiting in a red Cadillac outside. The officer entered the store and inquired
of the manager if everything was all right; the manager stated that a male
1
See Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738 (1967), and Commonwealth v.
Santiago, 978 A.2d 349, 361 (Pa. 2009).
J. S33010/15
in the store had been acting unusually, going in and out of the bathroom,
wandering aimlessly around the store, not making purchases and continually
asking a female employee at the sandwich counter if she had any
pornographic magazines. (Notes of testimony, 9/17/14 at 36-38.)
The officer identified himself to appellant and advised him that he was
under investigation for disorderly conduct in the store and requested
identification. Appellant identified himself as “Christian Decateres”;
appellant failed to produce identification. Subsequently, at the police
station, the officer learned appellant’s name was Moody.
On January 6, 2014, appellant was charged with disorderly conduct,
possession of drug paraphernalia, and false identification to law enforcement
officer. On June 17, 2014, appellant filed a motion for a competency
hearing, and the trial court ordered appellant to undergo a psychiatric
competency examination. The resulting psychiatric report stated appellant
was competent for trial. On September 17, 2014, a bench trial commenced.
The Commonwealth withdrew the counts of disorderly conduct and
possession of drug paraphernalia; appellant was found guilty of false
identification. Appellant waived a pre-sentence investigation and was
sentenced to one year of intermediate punishment, including a two-month
period of electronic home monitoring. On October 14, 2014, an alleged
family member forwarded the court a motion for a new trial; the document
bore appellant’s signature. The trial court treated this motion as a pro se
-2-
J. S33010/15
filing; but recognizing that appellant was still represented by counsel, the
court dismissed the pro se filing.
This timely appeal followed on October 16, 2014. The trial court
directed appellant to file a Pa.R.A.P. 1925(b) statement; subsequently,
counsel filed a statement of intent to file an Anders brief in lieu of filing a
statement. See Pa.R.A.P. 1925(c)(4). Consequently, the trial court filed a
Pa.R.A.P. 1925(a) opinion relying on counsel’s Rule 1925(c)(4) statement
without addressing any issues. (See trial court opinion, 1/2/15 at 3-4.)
As noted above, appellant’s counsel has filed a petition to withdraw
under Anders. When presented with an Anders brief, this court may not
review the merits of the underlying issues without first passing on the
request to withdraw. Commonwealth v. Goodwin, 928 A.2d 287, 290
(Pa.Super. 2007) (en banc). Before counsel is permitted to withdraw, he or
she must meet the following requirements:
First, counsel must petition the court for leave to
withdraw and state that after making a conscientious
examination of the record, he has determined that
the appeal is frivolous; second, he must file a brief
referring to any issues in the record of arguable
merit; and third, he must furnish a copy of the brief
to the defendant and advise him of his right to retain
new counsel or to himself raise any additional points
he deems worthy of the Superior Court’s attention.
Santiago, 978 A.2d at 351.
In the case sub judice, our review of counsel’s petition to withdraw,
correspondence advising appellant of his rights to proceed pro se or with
-3-
J. S33010/15
privately-retained counsel,2 and the Anders brief satisfies us that counsel
has complied with all of the foregoing requirements. We, therefore, turn to
the issue presented in counsel’s Anders brief to make an independent
judgment as to whether the appeal is, in fact, wholly frivolous. Santiago,
supra.
Appellate counsel has presented a single issue; namely, “whether the
illegal seizure tainted the balance of the investigation and rendered the
results of the investigation inadmissible at trial.” (Appellant’s brief at 3.) As
counsel states, this issue has been waived as appellant did not file a motion
to suppress. Following our review of the record, we agree and find this
claim waived due to appellant’s failure to preserve it. See Pa.R.A.P. 302(a)
(stating, “Issues not raised in the lower court are waived and cannot be
raised for the first time on appeal.”); Commonwealth v. Shamsud-Din,
995 A.2d 1224, 1228 (Pa.Super. 2010) (stating that “in order for a claim of
error to be preserved for appellate review, a party must make a timely and
specific objection before the trial court at the appropriate stage of the
proceedings; the failure to do so will result in waiver of the issue”).
Having determined the instant appeal is wholly frivolous, and after our
own independent review, we find there are no issues of arguable merit
apparent from the record. We will grant Attorney Blasetti’s petition to
withdraw and affirm the judgment of sentence.
2
Appellant has not filed a pro se brief or retained private counsel.
-4-
J. S33010/15
Petition to withdraw granted. Judgment of sentence affirmed.
Judgment Entered.
Joseph D. Seletyn, Esq.
Prothonotary
Date: 7/8/2015
-5-